Question about cost of apostasy

[Maria al-Qibtiyya]

[, Iwould like to tell you as well that Muslem have to accept all the rules of Islam, as we strongly belive that Almighty ALAH is Fair in His judgment
"إِنَّ اللّهَ لاَ يَظْلِمُ مِثْقَالَ ذَرَّةٍ وَإِن تَكُ حَسَنَةً يُضَاعِفْهَا

وَيُؤْتِ مِن لَّدُنْهُ أَجْرًا عَظِيمًا"

"ALLAH CAUSES NOT ANY INJUSTICE, EVEN TO THE SLIGHTEST EXTENT.

IF A GOOD DEED IS DONE, ALLAH WILL DOUBLE ITS MERIT,

AND HE WILL GIVE OF HIS OWN A GREAT REWARD."

the Holy Quran in Surah 4: Ayah 40 ,.
Muslem does not deal with ALLAH as he deals with humans ,we do not have the wrigt to discuse our Cretor
Surah 112: Ayahs 1-4:



قُلْ هُوَ اللَّهُ أَحَدٌ اللَّهُ الصَّمَدُ لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ وَلَمْ يَكُن لَّهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ

"SAY HE IS ALLAH THE ONE, ALLAH NEEDED BY ALL

HE BEGETS NOT NOR IS HE BEGOTTEN

AND THERE IS NONE THE LIKE OF HIM."[/LEFT]

Indeed true. Jazakallah for giving me all this. I'm not denying all these facts . What I'm saying sis is just that different scholars's opinions are different on this issue some say it's an obligation some say it's not , to kill an apostate. That is why I'm confused . & I know if an apostate is put to death it would be okay as Allah has allowed it . But I don't know if an apostate is left alive it would be a sin or not

[Maria al-Qibtiyya]

whats your first language ?

Irrelevant.

[واسطة العقد]

didnt say it is

[ليندا الموحدة بالله]

Yes if the apostate is still not convinced he is put to death in an Islamic state ruled under Shariah . There is consensus on this view.
There is no compulsion if you are a non-muslim. Once you have become a Muslim you are legally accountable for your actions such as stealing, drinking wine, committing adultery etc.Allah knows best.

[أميمة]

All scolars of Islam judge by killing a person who committed kofr but after enough discussion with him, according to the hadith of Bukhari whish is autheticated 100%
As told by brother Abu Alqasem

This is not the case for someone who is silent and does not make (fetna) in society , if some one knowes that he will be killed he will not make any problems and will not try to affect others (by net or news papers or T.V. or any way). in society

[Maria al-Qibtiyya]

This is not the case for someone who is silent and does not make (fetna) in society , if some one knowes that he will be killed he will not make any problems and will not try to affect others (by net or news papers or T.V. or any way). in society

So do you mean to say an apostate would not be put to death if he don't create fitnah, right??
And what is the punishment for a female apostate. some Muslims say , '' The female apostate will be given life imprisonment.'' is it true?

[Maria al-Qibtiyya]

.



This question was answered in the video

I'll watch in shaa Allah - jazakallah

[أبو القـاسم]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! the Video is Not right

[أبو القـاسم]

being non muslim is itself fetna..not as u said ..one of meanings of fetna is that it disturbs the belief of ignorant peopl in society and causes alot of good peopl to be confused..etc

[أبو القـاسم]

http://elazhar.com/okdown1/islam-guide.pdf

plz sis forget about this issue now..and kindly read this fantastic book

[lightline]

hope did post that video wasn't me

[أميمة]

In all "Abu Dawod " ref. there is no such this , and this means that this scholar is layer ,Is he Adnan Ibraheem?????

[Maria al-Qibtiyya]

Ok . i close this issue. killing an apostate is okay & don't worry i believe in Allah & acknowledge all His rules after all I'm a muslimah. And I was just asking a ''question'' it didnt affect on my belief. The scholar maye a liar. May Allah keep save all of us from such fake scholars.
I'd like to quote a Hadith: Abu Shamah had narrated, via the Sanad of Abi Ziyad bin Hudayr, saying:


"Omar said to me: Do you know what destroys Islam? I said, No! He said: A mistake made by a scholar, the argument of a hypocrite in writing and the ruling of leaders who wish for people to stray".
Wassalam.

[مسلم أسود]

Thank god that you're convinced . But I have a question :

Are you the same girl I told to come here on YouTube ?

[واسطة العقد]

اخي مسلم اسود: كلمة جودنيس ﻻ يجوز لنا كمسلمين قولها